The lower slope of a mansard roof is its defining feature and its most technically demanding roofing surface. At pitches ranging from 70 to 85 degrees from horizontal, sometimes steeper, the mansard lower slope is not a conventional roof surface in any meaningful installation sense. It is closer to a vertical wall that happens to be covered with roofing material rather than siding.
First, drainage. On a conventional roof pitch water flows down the slope by gravity and exits at the eave. On a near-vertical mansard slope water does not flow, it sheets. The velocity of water sheeting down a near-vertical surface is significantly higher than water flowing down a standard pitch, and the force of that sheeting water acts against every shingle edge, every flashing lap, and every penetration seal on the lower slope simultaneously during a Louisiana rainfall event. Standard shingle installation at the overlap and fastening dimensions designed for conventional pitches do not adequately resist the penetration force of high-velocity sheeting water on a near-vertical surface.
Second, fastening. Shingles installed on a near-vertical surface are subject to gravity-driven downward pull in addition to wind uplift forces. On a conventional pitch gravity acts perpendicular to the roof surface, pressing the shingle into the deck. On a near-vertical pitch gravity acts nearly parallel to the surface, pulling the shingle downward along the face of the roof. Fasteners that are adequate to resist perpendicular uplift may not be adequate to resist the combination of perpendicular uplift and parallel downward pull simultaneously. On a Denham Springs mansard roof in Louisiana’s wind environment this combined loading is a real and recurring failure mechanism.
Third, wind pressure. Louisiana’s hurricane and tropical storm winds act against the near-vertical lower slope of a mansard roof with the same force they act against an exterior wall because, for all practical aerodynamic purposes, that is what the lower slope is. Direct wind pressure against the full face of the lower slope creates uplift at the shingle edges and inward pressure against the sheathing and framing simultaneously. This is a wind loading condition that is more analogous to wall cladding performance than conventional roof shingle performance, and it should be evaluated as such in every mansard roof installation and inspection.